With the highly anticipated "To All the Boys: P.S. I Still Love You," being less than a month away from release, I figured it was time to answer the big question. Who would you choose? Peter Kavinsky or John Ambrose McClaren?


About Peter Kavinsky

  • Age: 17
  • Height: 6'1"
  • Job: His mother owns an antique store, which he sometimes helps out with.
  • Hobby: He plays lacrosse (look for number 15).
  • Favorite movie: "Fight Club"

Peter's Preferences:

  • Dogs or cats? DOGS
  • Night owl or morning person? More of a night owl, for sure.
  • Taylor Swift or Beyoncé? Beyonce, definitely.
  • Baby Yoda or Baby Groot? I AM GROOT.

Three qualities Peter is looking for in a partner:

  1. Someone who has seen, or would be down to watch, "Fight Club."
  2. Someone who will cheer him on at his games.
  3. Someone who will make him cinnamon toast (it's his favorite food).

About John Ambrose McClaren

  • Age: 17
  • Height: 5'8"
  • Job: Student right now, trying to get into college and Model UN.
  • Hobby: Volunteering at the nursing home where his grandma is at.
  • Favorite flavor: Peanut butter and chocolate

John Ambrose's Preferences:

  • Dogs or cats? Dogs, but both are fine really.
  • Night owl or morning person? More of a morning person
  • Taylor Swift or Beyoncé? Taylor Swift has some great songs to be honest...
  • Baby Yoda or Baby Groot? Baby Yoda!

Three qualities John Ambrose is looking for in a partner:

  1. Someone who will bake him a cake (preferably a peanut butter chocolate cake with his name written in Reese's Pieces).
  2. Someone he can have as a pen pal.
  3. Someone who is fun to play games with.

So, who would you choose? Make your decision quickly! "To All The Boys 2: P.S. I Still Love You" airs on Netflix February 12!

Want to create a funny dating profile for a friend or fictional character?

Click here for our easy-to-use template you'll just have to copy and paste.

Follow Swoon on Instagram.